I welcome the publication of From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation, the independent review led by Alan Milburn and commissioned by the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions to examine the growing number of young people who are not in education, employment or training.

There is much in the review that those of us working with children, young people and communities should welcome.

In particular, I welcome its recognition that we cannot wait until a young person is 16, 18 or 21 and has become disengaged from education, employment or their community before we act.

Prevention has to start much earlier.

I particularly welcome the review’s recognition of the importance of play and childhood itself.

In paragraphs 362 to 364, the review makes a statement that should be compulsory reading for anyone developing policy for children:

“Childhood has value in its own right.”

It says children need time and space to read, play, make friends, participate in sport, music and the arts, explore their interests, take reasonable risks and learn to relate to other people. It goes on to recognise that confidence, communication, resilience, curiosity and teamwork develop over years through family life, friendship, play, sport, creativity, school and community participation.

Perhaps most powerfully, the review concludes:

“Preparing young people well for adulthood begins with allowing them to have a childhood.”

For those of us in Playwork, that feels enormously important.

It also feels remarkably familiar.

Because, in many respects, the review is describing what the Playwork sector has been saying and doing for generations.

We have known this for a long time

This year marks 80 years since Marjory Allen, Lady Allen of Hurtwood (née Gill, 1897–1976) published her hugely influential article Why Not Use Our Bomb Sites Like This? in Picture Post on 16 November 1946.

Lady Allen was a landscape architect and campaigner for children’s welfare who became one of the most influential figures in the development of adventure playgrounds in Britain. English Heritage describes her as a pioneering landscape architect, child-welfare campaigner and important figure in the establishment of adventure playgrounds in the UK.

Inspired by the junk playground at Emdrup in Copenhagen, she returned to Britain convinced that children needed places where they could build, experiment, explore and create rather than simply use equipment adults had decided to provide for them.

In language reflecting the concerns of its time, her 1946 article connected inadequate opportunities for creative play with wider social concerns, including road danger and juvenile delinquency. More fundamentally, however, her argument was about children’s environments. She believed children’s desire for adventure and exploration should be enabled rather than continually restricted.

That article helped inspire Britain’s adventure-playground movement. The practice, theory and professional identity that we now know as Playwork developed subsequently from this movement and related forms of children’s play provision.

Eighty years later, we are still making a remarkably similar argument:

If we want different outcomes for children, we have to think seriously about the environments, relationships, freedoms and opportunities we provide throughout childhood.

You cannot invest in children at four, stop at five and expect to pick them back up at eleven

For more than 20 years, one of the things we have consistently argued at MASKK is that there is a huge gap in how we think about childhood.

We quite rightly invest significant attention and public resources in the early years. We recognise that those first years of children’s lives matter enormously.

Then children turn five.

Too often, universal community support reduces and school is expected to carry an increasing amount of responsibility for almost everything that follows.

Then, as children approach adolescence, we rediscover the importance of relationships, trusted adults, positive activities, community and youth work.

But what happens between five and eleven?

  • Children don’t stop developing when they start school.
  • They don’t stop needing trusted adults.
  • They don’t stop needing community.
  • They don’t stop needing opportunities to make friends, experience challenge, make decisions, negotiate conflict, test boundaries, explore who they are and discover what they are capable of.
  • And they certainly don’t stop needing to play.

At MASKK, we describe this as the missing middle: the years after early-years provision and before most youth provision becomes available.

We cannot invest heavily in early childhood, drop children at five, and then expect them automatically to engage again when youth provision becomes available around eleven.

Playwork belongs in that middle.

The review recognises play. But where are the Playworkers?

This is my central concern with the Milburn Review.

  • The review recognises play.
  • It recognises friendships.
  • It recognises reasonable risk.
  • It recognises relationships.
  • It recognises community participation.
  • It recognises that preparing children well for adulthood starts considerably earlier than employment programmes at 16.

And yet the review does not explicitly recognise Playwork or Playworkers as a distinct professional discipline.

This omission is particularly noticeable because the review explicitly recommends increasing the number of specialist youth workers and expanding activities available to young people, particularly in areas with high numbers of young people at risk of becoming NEET.

That matters.

  • Playwork is not simply “doing activities with children”.
  • It isn’t youth work for younger children.
  • It isn’t childcare under a different name.
  • And it certainly isn’t sports coaching without the football.

Playwork is a distinct professional discipline.

The Government’s own Skills England framework recognises Playworker as approved technical occupation OCC0867, supported by the Level 2 Playworker apprenticeship standard ST0867.

The occupational standard describes Playworkers creating stimulating and adventurous environments in which children can learn and explore in their own way, following their own intentions, ideas and inventions. It specifically identifies settings including before and after-school clubs, adventure playgrounds, mobile play provision, holiday schemes, parks and woodlands.

Just as importantly, the standard describes Playwork as focusing on child-directed and child-controlled play. It recognises that Playworkers observe rather than automatically lead children’s activity and reflect on whether their own adult presence is helping or negatively affecting children’s play.

The professional recognition therefore already exists within government.

We now need that recognition reflected consistently in policy, planning and investment.

Lady Allen understood the importance of the environment

One of the things I find particularly relevant about Lady Allen’s work today is that she didn’t simply ask what was “wrong” with children.

She challenged adults to think about the environments we were creating for them.

Her landmark book Planning for Play, first published by Thames & Hudson in 1968, argued that children’s play needed to be taken seriously in the planning of the places where people lived. Her approach valued adventure, informality, nature and environments rich enough for children to explore and manipulate.

That distinction remains incredibly important today.

When a child struggles with attendance, behaviour, relationships or regulation, our instinct can be to ask:

“What intervention does this child need?”

Sometimes we also need to ask:

“What does this child’s environment need?”

  • Where can they go?
  • Where can they play?
  • Where can they make noise?
  • Where can they meet friends?
  • Where can they get messy?
  • Where can they take reasonable risks?
  • Where can they make choices?
  • Where can they spend time with trusted adults without constantly being assessed, taught or treated?
  • Where can they simply be a child?

Those are fundamentally Playwork questions.

Playwork and youth work are complementary, not interchangeable

I want to be absolutely clear that this is not an argument against youth work.

Quite the opposite.

We need properly resourced, professional youth work.

The National Youth Agency, the Professional, Statutory and Regulatory Body for youth work in England, describes youth workers as building voluntary, trusted relationships with young people away from many of the pressures they face elsewhere. It says youth workers usually work with young people aged 11 to 19, although they may support young adults up to 25 depending on their needs.

That is vital work.

And youth work itself has faced serious pressures. I do not want the case for Playwork to become an argument about taking recognition or resources away from another valuable profession.

But Playwork and youth work should not simply be collapsed into one generic children’s and young people’s workforce. They are related and complementary professions, but they are not interchangeable.

We need strong Playwork throughout childhood and strong youth work as children move through adolescence, with effective relationships and transitions between them.

We already contribute to many of the outcomes the review wants

When I read the Milburn Review, I recognise many outcomes to which good Playwork provision already contributes.

Prevention

Open-access Playwork can provide support and positive relationships without necessarily requiring children to reach a threshold, receive a diagnosis or become a “case” first.

Belonging

Children can develop connections with other children, adults, neighbourhoods and community spaces.

Trusted relationships

Playworkers can become consistent adults in children’s lives without every conversation having to become a formal intervention.

SEND inclusion

Good Playwork environments can adapt around children rather than continually expecting children to adapt themselves around services.

This also connects strongly with the legacy of Lady Allen. During the 1970s she was instrumental in establishing the organisation then called the Handicapped Adventure Playground Association, developing adventurous play opportunities for disabled children.

Attendance and engagement

Playwork cannot, and should not, claim that it solves persistent absence.

But trusted community relationships, confidence, belonging, friendships and opportunities to experience competence can form part of the network of support surrounding a child whose connection with school is weakening.

This is particularly relevant because the Milburn Review calls for continued attention to persistent absence and exclusions and recommends Risk of NEET Indicator tools in both primary and secondary schools.

Transitions

Playwork can also provide continuity around the crucial transition between primary and secondary school.

The Milburn Review itself says this transition deserves “much greater attention” because failure at this point can be difficult to reverse.

A park, adventure playground, community organisation or trusted Playworker can potentially remain consistent while almost everything else around the child changes.

Prevention of later disengagement

The pathway isn’t difficult to understand:

Play → relationships → belonging → confidence and agency → engagement → successful transitions → continued participation.

We should be careful with causation here.

Playwork cannot claim responsibility for whether somebody is employed at 21 simply because they attended a playground at eight. But we can argue that Playwork contributes to many of the protective factors that the review itself considers important: relationships, confidence, communication, resilience, curiosity, social connection and participation in community life.

That is a credible and important contribution.

The difference is capacity and investment

This is where we need an honest conversation.

The Playwork sector cannot deliver at the scale required because its infrastructure has not received sufficient sustained recognition or investment.

Much universal and community Playwork in England remains dependent upon combinations of charitable fundraising, grants, donations, commissioned projects and short-term programmes.

That affects capacity.

  • It affects workforce development.
  • It affects salaries and career progression.
  • It affects organisational stability.
  • It affects whether an adventure playground, community project or play scheme can confidently tell children: “We’ll still be here next year.”
  • Ultimately, it affects how many children get to play.

We should also be careful not to suggest that youth work enjoys a simple guaranteed statutory funding settlement. It does not, and the youth-work sector has itself endured significant financial insecurity.

The distinction I want government to address is this:

Playwork in England lacks a dedicated statutory play-sufficiency duty and a secure universal funding settlement.

That leaves much Playwork provision dependent upon the ability of charities, community organisations and local partnerships to secure funding again and again.

The history of adventure playgrounds illustrates that vulnerability. According to London Museum, London had around 100 adventure playgrounds by the late 1970s. More than 70 remained in 2025, but some had reduced their services or closed as councils faced financial pressures and playgrounds struggled to fund staffing.

Simply putting the word “play” into public policy is therefore not enough.

  • If government wants children to play, children need somewhere to do it.
  • If we want inclusive, adventurous and adaptable play environments, somebody needs to create, resource and maintain them.
  • If we want skilled adults who understand when to intervene and, crucially, when not to intervene, we need Playworkers.
  • And if we want provision consistently available to children in communities experiencing the greatest disadvantage, we have to invest in it.

We invest either side of middle childhood

The policy gap becomes particularly stark when we look at childhood as a whole.

At one end, we have substantial policy attention around the early years. At the other, we increasingly recognise the importance of youth work, adolescence, transitions and preparation for adulthood.

Between them sit millions of primary-aged children. They are not simply school pupils between 9am and 3pm.

They are children.

  • They need parks, streets, playgrounds, woodlands, neighbourhoods and community spaces where they can discover their world.
  • They need opportunities that aren’t always structured around a lesson, sporting outcome, measurable intervention or predetermined adult objective.
  • They need adults who understand play.
  • Some need a trusted adult who will still be there tomorrow, next week and next year.

That should not depend on whether a community charity manages to win its next funding application.

The lesson from 1946 should make us uncomfortable

Perhaps the most striking thing about revisiting Lady Allen’s writing today is how contemporary the underlying questions sound.

Her influential 1946 article followed her experience of the Emdrup junk playground in Copenhagen and helped popularise the argument that children needed opportunities for experimentation, construction and adventurous play rather than simply conventional fixed playground equipment.

Then, in 1968, Planning for Play again made the case that children’s play needed to be taken seriously when we design the environments in which families live.

Lady Allen died in 1976. Yet in 2026 we are still having to persuade policy-makers that children’s ability to play requires planning, skilled people, physical space and sustained investment.

Perhaps the question isn’t whether we have enough evidence.

Perhaps the question is:

How much more evidence do we need before children’s play becomes part of our social infrastructure rather than an optional extra?

Sheffield can demonstrate another approach

Here in Sheffield, we have an opportunity to do something different.

Through MASKK, Pitsmoor Adventure Playground, Adventures and the Sheffield Play Partnership, we are working to strengthen Playwork practice, workforce development and opportunities for children’s play across the city. Alongside a strong youth-work sector, Sheffield has the opportunity to demonstrate what a genuine pathway through childhood and adolescence could look like:

Early Years → Playwork → Youth Work → Adulthood

  • Not completely separate systems repeatedly rediscovering the same children.
  • Not intense attention during early childhood, a gap through the primary years, followed by a new attempt to establish relationships when children reach adolescence.

Instead, imagine a continuum.

Different professionals. Different approaches. Different developmental stages. Connected around the same children, families and communities.

This also provides an opportunity for Playworkers and youth workers to work together particularly carefully around the transition from primary to secondary education, precisely the point the Milburn Review identifies as needing much greater attention.

This is why we are calling for change

At MASKK, we welcome the direction of the Milburn Review.

But we will also continue to challenge the absence of explicit recognition for Playwork within the wider policy conversation.

We call upon local government, national government and policymakers across England to recognise the gap in investment in universal Playwork provision.

We want to see:

  • Playwork recognised explicitly as a distinct profession, alongside early years, youth work, sport and other children’s professions.
  • Universal Playwork recognised as part of our preventative infrastructure, rather than something communities continually have to recreate through short-term projects.
  • Qualified Playworkers included in appropriate commissioning and funding frameworks.
  • Playwork represented in policy discussions affecting primary-aged children, particularly around SEND, attendance, inclusion, enrichment, community safety and school transitions.
  • Sustained investment in adventure playgrounds, open-access community Playwork, play-ranger services, parks-based provision, holiday Playwork and high-quality school-based Playwork.
  • Recognition and use of the existing Playwork occupational standards, qualifications and workforce, including the new Occupational Standards for Playwork.
  • Stronger connections between Early Years, Playwork and Youth Work, giving children continuity rather than allowing them to fall between departments, professions and funding programmes.

Above all, children’s ability to play should not depend upon the fundraising ability of the charity trying to provide it.

Play has value now, not simply because of what children might become

There is one final point we cannot afford to lose.

In responding to concerns about future employment and economic inactivity, we must not turn childhood into preparation for the labour market.

The Milburn Review explicitly makes this distinction. It says preparing young people for adult working life:

“cannot mean turning childhood into an ever-earlier rehearsal for work.”

That sentence matters enormously.

Children need to play because they are children now, not simply because playing might make them more employable in ten years’ time.

  • A seven-year-old building a den isn’t practising construction for their future career.
  • Children negotiating the rules of a game haven’t enrolled themselves on a teamwork course.
  • A child climbing higher than they did yesterday isn’t completing a resilience intervention.

They are playing.

  • And extraordinary things can happen through that play.
  • Relationships develop.
  • Confidence can grow.
  • Disagreements are navigated.
  • Risks are judged.
  • Ideas are tested.
  • Children discover what their bodies can do, what their communities contain, how other people respond to them and who they are.

These things matter.

But they emerge precisely because the activity belongs to the child.
That distinction sits at the heart of Playwork.

Eighty years later, the challenge remains

In 1946, Lady Allen of Hurtwood asked Britain to think differently about the places and opportunities we provided for children.

Her campaigning helped inspire Britain’s adventure-playground movement and contributed to a tradition of practice from which modern Playwork subsequently developed. Eighty years later, we should ask ourselves whether we have fully learned that lesson.

The Milburn Review strengthens the case we have been making for more than two decades at MASKK:

Prevention cannot begin at sixteen.

  • Relationships matter.
  • Community matters.
  • Belonging matters.
  • Inclusion matters.
  • Play matters.
  • And the years between starting school and becoming a teenager matter enormously.

So we welcome the review.

But we also take its logic one step further:

If government recognises that play contributes to the foundations children need for later life, it must recognise and invest in the professional workforce that supports and facilitates high-quality play.

  • We need investment in early years.
  • We need investment in youth work.
  • And between them, we need investment in Playwork.
  • Children shouldn’t disappear from our preventative policy at five and magically reappear at eleven.
  • The missing middle matters.

And, as our sector continues to remind policymakers:

It all starts with play.

Craig Judson
Chief Executive Officer
MASKK – Manor After School & Kids Klubs